Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Diabetes is Treated Better with Surgery plus Medical Management than Medical Management Alone

Many of you may have read or heard about an important study published in the New England Medical Journal on March 26, 2012. Dr. Phil Schaur and his colleagues at the Cleveland Clinic completed a trial that has very profound implications for patients with Type 2 diabetes.

They compared 50 poorly controlled diabetic patients who had intensive medical management of their diabetes to 50 patients treated with a laparoscopic gastric bypass plus medical therapy and another 50 patients who were treated with a laparoscopic gastric sleeve plus medical therapy.

There was no mortality and complications were low.

The primary finding was that at the end of 1 year the patients who had surgery plus medical therapy achieved much better control of their diabetes. In fact, nearly 4 times as many patients in the surgery plus medical therapy group achieved excellent diabetic control than the group receiving only intensive medical therapy.

Between the two surgical options, the laparoscopic gastric bypass patients did somewhat better than the laparoscopic gastric sleeve patients.

Another important finding was that those receiving only intensive medical therapy increased the number of medicines they had to take over the year while those who had surgery plus medical therapy decreased the number of diabetic medicines and often were on no diabetic medicines at all.

Although it will be helpful to continue to follow these patients for several more years to evaluate the long term effects of better control, it is very clear that patients with type 2 diabetes do better if they have bariatric surgery than those who do not choose to have surgery.

Several months ago I mentioned that the medical establishment was too slow in accepting the remarkable improvement in diabetes after bariatric surgery. Could there be a sea change coming with this and other studies?

6 comments:

  1. One of the many positive findings relating to gastric bypass surgery. To learn more about each of these procedures, please visit: Pacific Bariatric

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excercise and diet is the first thing that comes up in our mind if we want to shed those extra weight and it really helps a lot. Decipline and determination is the first key to success, but we always wanted the easiest way. Many people considered lapband as their last option but is it safe? I was searching the internet and I just would like to ask this question if you heared anything about it, the link is - youtube.com/user/RocaLabsReviews and it says that it will give you a gastric bypass result but no surgery at all...any info?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have heard about that product and it says it will give you a feeling of fullness every time you take it and will help you eliminate food cravings too... not sure though if it will also work on me.. I have tried a lot of weight loss programs and pills but none of them work.. hope this one will help me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My son lost 7 lbs in just two weeks use of the product. He mixes it with apple juice since he doesn't like it plain...

    ReplyDelete
  5. I believe that non-surgical treatments for obesity are much more effective that weight loss surgery. I am using a gastric bypass alternative called Roca Labs Formula. I have been successfully losing weight without having to worry of having any life threatening complications.

    ReplyDelete
  6. ** Safer alternative to gastric bypass surgery **
    Everyone should have an alternative to weight loss surgery. Roca Labs is a safer and cheaper alternative to gastric bypass. I found information to this product at RocaLabs.com.

    ReplyDelete